I liked it a lot; it’s been a while since a horror movie has scared me that much.
To me, it’s a movie that’s largely about the horror of being in a relationship with someone who is mentally unwell. It was really hitting my “borderline personality disorder” flags, I guess, but a very heightened version of them. Every tiny sign that he might not love her is a betrayal, she’s extremely clingy, and the transgressions and horrors are matched with this manipulation, social pressure, and excuse. He says, “why would you do that, you’re freaking me out” and she says “oh I’m so so sorry, I’ll never do it ever again”. And obviously her having some kind of psychotic break is brought up multiple times in the movie, making it at least somewhat an endorsed reading by the text.
And obviously it’s not all that, because it’s also a very funny movie in parts, and there are layers to it; it would probably have been a failure if there was a single straightforward reading. Bear is a coward as one of his defining features, and goes along with way too much because of that, unable to stand up for himself, to state what he’s feeling, particularly susceptible to this kind of monstrous torture. Naïve too, in a way that makes it all worse for him.
I made the mistake of reading some Letterboxd reviews, and it’s definitely one of those movies that makes me feel like other people watched a different movie from the one I did. There are parts of the movie that feel to me like they were 5% of it, and seem to be getting all the attention, and … I get it, people have different preferences and priorities, but it’s difficult for me to read the movie in those ways. I don’t think that it was largely a movie about autonomy, but that element is definitely there . It’s just not where I felt the focus was, so I feel like it’s a movie I’ll end up talking past people about.